This was orginally published on the SGR Blog.
Street parking space is an extremely valuable commodity in New York City, in general, and in densely populated residential neighborhoods, in particular. A recent spat between neighbors in Brooklyn implicated both the statute and case law governing the several elements of a claim of title by adverse possession, with the overlay of two Court-made rules or doctrines, as well as a legal presumption and a shifting burden of proof.
Waterview Towers, Inc. and 2610 Cropsey Development Corp. are owners of properties in Brooklyn that abut Centre Place, a private driveway/street. Waterview owns tax block 6933, lot 55. Cropsey owns tax block 6933, lots 48 and 51. A small parking area has existed along the half of Centre Place abutting the Waterview property since prior to Cropsey’s purchase of the neighboring lot in 2005.
Continue reading